With Hollywood out of ideas, I have no doubt there's some transplanted Pittsburgher out there (Michael Keaton?) who will someday make a movie about the Pirates. This movie will feature Pirates past and present, with some real surprise cameos thrown in. Some of these, we have previously leaked to you; some of these have just been announced. With that in mind, here is a preliminary casting that we were somehow able to get our hands on.
Any suggestions, please leave in the comment section and we will do our best to add them!
OF Craig Wilson will be played by Family Guy's Chris Griffin

The Ultimate Pirate, Derek Bell, played by Blackbeard the Pirate

Catcher Humberto Cota will be played by American Pie's Chris Klein

Infielder Jack Wilson and Malcolm in the Middle star Frankie Muniz

OF Jason Bay will be played by the Muppets' Beaker

OF Jeromy Burnitz will be played by the late, great Pirate Honus Wagner

Former P Jimmy Anderson will be portrayed by Jabba the Hutt


Infielder Joe Randa will be played by The Jack Nicholson Joker

Jonah "Don't Call Me Skip" Bayliss, played by Justin Timberlake

Not-always-motivated-to-run-out-grounders 2B Jose Castillo and Looney Tunes' Slowpoke Rodriguez

Strikeout machine/3B Jose Hernandez will be played by The Letter K of Sesame Street

Pitcher Kip Wells, because he is Kip Dynamite, played by Kip Dynamite. Discussed ad nauseum on this site.

Outfielder Nate McLouth will be played by Remember the Titans QB "Sunshine"

Pitcher Oliver Perez will be played by a Jugs Pitching Machine

Former OF Raul Mondesi will be played by the always angry Ice-T

"Closer" Roberto Hernandez will be played by Lethal Weapon's Danny Glover

Former 3B Ty Wigginton will be played by a yet-to-be-announced member of ZZ Top

Former Skipper Lloyd McClendon will be played by Bernie Mac

Manager Jim Tracy will be played by Office Space boss Bill Lumbergh

Announcer Greg Brown played by Sesame Street's Guy Smiley

Announcer John Wehner, played by Steelers Coach Bill Cowher

Announcer Lanny Frattare, played by The Simpsons' Ned Flanders


Perennial Prospective Owner Mark Cuban and American Idol's Taylor Hicks

GM Dave Littlefield, played by Seinfeld's Kramer, Michael Richards
(Much credit to industry insider Mike at Steeltown Sports for this one!)

Owner G. Ogden Nutting will be played by The Simpsons' C. Montgomery Burns. Note the extra similarity that they both go by their first initial.

Kevin McClatchy, whipping boy of Ogden Nutting, will naturally be played by Waylon Smithers


More casting to be announced as we receive the details from the studio!